Monday 28 December 2009

Colnago CX-1 Review

So, I've been threatening to do a write-up about my Colnago CX-1 since the first day I got it, but having now owned it for a more suitable length of time in which to appraise it (some 8 months), it's time to put down my impressions.

My CX-1 was a frame only purchase, so it's a mix of some new and some previously used equipment. For those wanting to take a browse of the CX-1 full specs, below is the link:

Colnago CX-1 2010 Model.

Mine is the 2009 model, so the colour scheme (.ACRE) is a little different from the 2010 model: the BB area on mine is black where the 2010 is red, and the 'club' logos preceding the Colnago name decals are also black where again, those of the 2010 are red.

General Details

My CX-1 is the 2009 .ACRE model in size 54s (sloping). Definitely a smaller size in terms of designation, but in reality the measurements are in fact slightly longer in the wheelbase and TT than most bikes I've owned. So, if you're interested in going the Colnago way, do some fit research: they are definitely a slightly unique defined sizing.

Equipment

As I said, I purchased the CX-1 as a frame/fork only, and hence it is a mix of previously used parts and newly purchased ones.

Derailleur mechs, brifters and brakes are good old Shimano Dura Ace 7800 – I really love this equipment in terms of functionality, fit and form: just feels really good to me particularly in the hoods area. Rear cluster is an Ultegra 12-23: DA is just a bit too expensive in this area. Chain is the new 7900 DA – wanted the master link: it works fine with the DA/Ultegra mechs and cluster.

Cockpit area is a 3T Ergosum Team shallow drop bar, with the aforementioned DA 7800 brifters, Fizik Microtex tape, and Shimano Flight Deck mated to a Ritchey WCS alu 110 mm stem.

Seat and tube are a Fizik Arione Ti and Ritchey WCS carbon 31.6mm two-bolt respectively.

Chainset is a FSA SL-K double (53-39) on a Hope Ceramic anodised red BB.

Wheels are newly purchased Campy Eurus 2-Way Fit mated to Vittoria Rubino Pro Tyres.

Here's what it looks like overall:

CX-1 Right side

Clearly I'm into red, white and black :)

Frame Structure and Finish

The CX-1 is a front monocoque triangle mated to a lugged rear bonded triangle: front mono and rear assembly is manufactured in Taiwan and bonded in Italy. Not sure what it actually weighs, but then at 90kg, I'm not that much of a weight weenie: can't say I've ever bought a component based on its weight (or lack thereof).

The front triangle tubes are what is termed of a 'polygon' shape: a cross between a square and circular cross section, with the top and bottom sections being flat and the sides being an arc of a circle. The idea is that as a square beam it resists vertical bending, and as a circular based shape it resists twisting. Below are a couple of pics of the DT and TT which sort of illustrates the shape.

CX-1 Downtube

CX-1 TT logo

It is a fairly hefty architecture, certainly not what I'd term aero: looks like a beefy sprinter's bike. Mated to a massive bottom bracket and a substantial head tube 1 and 1/8 top and bottom with Colnago's HS2 semi-integrated design, Colnago's own carbon fork, and large rectangular chain stays, it all spells Stiff.

CX-1 BB and chainstays

CX-1 BB left

The finish is gorgeous: lovely deep colours and tasteful bits of naked carbon show through via all the logos and BB. Only downside is the white paint: one or two small chips show thru' the black carbon of the forks. To ameliorate that I purchased some of that protective vinyl coating used on car fronts and installed it on the front of the forks, the head set and under the downtube.

Rider Interface

The cockpit as set up is simple and basic and well suited to me: always been a fan of Flight Deck. The 3T bar is great, shape and appearance wise, and the compact short drops are perfect for someone a little less flexible. Am a big fan of the Fizik bar tape: grippy with enough cushioning and easy clean.

CX-1 Cockpit front

CX-1 Cockpit

Have owned an Arione since they first came out, and it's the first seat I've never really had to think about. It basically disappears under me, which is probably the best recommendation for fit one can give. I'm not into huge long rides, but 140km journeys haven't raised any issues at all.

CX-1 Seat and post

Mechanicals

Not much to say here: the DA 7800 stuff mixed with the FSA chainset and the Ultegra cluster and the 7900 chain just work very well, and that's all.

CX-1 Rear cluster

The Hope Ceramic BB setup is really nice: a straight fit onto the FSA chainset spindle, and certainly feels smooth and free-spinning. I'm not much of a foul weather rider, so exposure isn't an issue. Interesting to see how long it'll spin for.

Ride

The bike as set up is a revelation to me. Absolutely the stiffest bike I've ever owned, the frame and wheelset cope with my 90kg with no issues at all. There is no evidence of twist, slump or bending at all from the head tube, BB or anywhere else, either in or out of saddle. This is a frame that is designed to handle way more than my meager power output – frankly it's overkill for me.

And yet, along with that extreme stiffness comes a degree of vertical comfort and compliance which is a little surprising: I'd seriously expected the bike to have been slightly compromised compared to my other previous carbon bikes in this regard, but it isn't. Obviously, the carbon bar and seat post are helping, but I certainly don't think that's the complete story. The convex rear seat stays are clearly working well here and there is some 'magic' in the frame that provides a level of stiffness with compliance which is just great. I could ride this bike for as long as I wanted over all but the most broken tarmac and not be at all phased.

And even if it wasn't as vertically compliant I doubt I'd complain: the CX-1 is just the most sharp and deftly handling bike I've ever swung a leg over. Its ability to follow a line – any line – is telepathic, and even when the choice of line isn't the greatest it'll eat up whatever you throw at it. It is a quick steerer, but not at all nervous – there are no over-corrections or adjustments required.

Downhill it is an absolute rock: not a twitch, wiggle or millimetre off line. You just look to where you want to go and it does the rest. It just 'flows'. Without a doubt the most stress free ride at 75km/h and plus ever for me.

And it soaks up road imperfections and significant lumps and bumps with outright ease. Not a good thing perhaps, but I've pretty much stopped looking out for stuff to dodge on the roads: only very large imperfections or objects would have me taking active evasive action.

Whilst I'm no mountain goat, the bike throws up no obstacles to my climbing: however good or bad I am on the day, it's all me.

It is the complete bike for me and I'm all the better for riding it. This bike makes me a better rider full stop. And every time I swing my leg off the bike I've felt the best I ever had about a ride – and that says it all.

Thanks Ernesto!

CX-1 Ernesto Sig

Ride safe!

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

read your review- I just purchased a 2011 CX-1 frameset. Looking forward to building it up and riding.

Anonymous said...

I’m just on to a CX1 and thought I’d contribute for those looking at this purchase – Short Summary – DO IT.

All the above is an excellent description of how my CX1 feels also. (I wish I’d read your review prior to making my internet purchase as it would have taken any qualms totally away).

I live in Brisbane, bought the bike used from Adelaide, although I had a friend check it out for me during Tour Down Under and I did trial a 2012 version of the CX1 which I liked instantly but the increased area around the headset meant it was not “exactly” what I was looking to purchase. The groupset is Campag Super Record which is very nice, and will ideally stay this way for many years to come. I am a very recent convert out from Shimano Dura-Ace, partly just looking for something different which I enjoyed as I have been riding a borrowed C50 bike with the Record groupset.

The C50 is a stiffer frame than the CX1, which is most noticeable on climbs, but it is stiff in a “I shall not be moved” type of way, as opposed to the CX1 which I find stiff but responsive and enjoyable on the climbs. I have found the C50’s vertical stiffness discomforting over non-perfect roads feeling every bump. Part of the problem with the borrowed C50 was the 135g saddle that came with it, perhaps if I’d put my old / alternative saddle on it would be a bit more forgiving over the full ride.

I like to climb most, and the bike ticks this box very nicely indeed. At 73kg and 175cm I am not monstering the bike on either the climbs or flats, but feel the power transferred directly to the bottom bracket in all instances.

Descents are enjoyable, eating up the bumps very nicely. It also feels responsive in steering and I look forward to becoming more acquainted with this.

The look is superb, with the tubing not bulky, being close to traditional metal, just a bit more chunky. The exposed carbon is nicely balanced with the painted sections. The trend in curved tubing may leave us soon, whereas I am confident the more traditional looking compact frame will always be classic.

I am very pleased. I just need more time on it and better legs.

Matt B

Groupset – Super Record
Wheels – Mavic Cosmic Carbones, SLR
Saddle – Selle Gel Flow
Handlebars – Deba Zero 100

lrjh750f1 aka Leonard Hannaby said...

Cheers Matt B

Glad you enjoyed the review and thanks for your contribution - a great read!

Keep enjoying your CX-1 - I know everytime I sling my leg over the bike I still get a sense of anticipation of the ride to come.

Cheers,
lrjh750f1